Origins of germ cell tumours unravelled giving possible opportunities for future treatment
Researchers have studied the root of germ cell tumours and revealed molecular signatures that could help guide the course of treatment in the future.
New research has detailed the origins of germ cell tumours, which are derived from the cells that give rise to sperm or eggs. The results shed light on how these tumours develop, and reveal possible future avenues for novel therapies.
Scientists from the Wellcome Sanger Institute, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, and collaborators, uncovered that even though these tumours appear at different ages and can contain multiple cell types, their mutational origins can often be traced back to a genetic event that happened by chance in the womb. In addition to this, these tumours utilise similar pathways of growth as normal tissues which could represent a potential target for treatment.
The research, published today (11 August 2022) in Nature Communications, also observed that tumours which develop before puberty carry distinct patterns of mutations, known as mutational signatures. While further investigation is needed, these could be used in the future to help inform clinical decisions when it comes to treating children with germ cell tumours.
Malignant germ cell tumours can appear at any age and are one of the most common cancers of adolescent and young men1. They also account for approximately 5 per cent of all childhood cancers2, with around 45 children being diagnosed every year in the UK3.
Germ cell tumours can be made up from a variety of cell types, including muscle, placenta or teeth and hair in some cases. The cell types that the tumour is composed of has implications for the prognosis, as some can be more aggressive than others. This study looked at how these tissues develop together within tumours, and contrasts them with how healthy tissues grow, which has not previously been possible.
In this new research, scientists from the Wellcome Sanger Institute, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, and their collaborators, examined tumour samples from 15 individuals. By applying in-depth genetic sequencing techniques, they were able to study the DNA and RNA of all the different tissues they sampled within the tumours at an unprecedented resolution.
By analysing this extensive amount of genetic information, the team were able to trace the mutational origin of the tumours all the way back to the beginning of their development in the womb. It is unknown what causes the tumours to develop, and the initial mutation appears to happen by chance. They found that the way tumours created tissues, such as cartilage or muscle, shared similarities with how those are created in a growing embryo which may represent novel treatment targets.
The researchers also identified different mutational signatures in tumours of young children compared with tumour samples taken from older children, over the age of 12. Therefore, the mutational signatures the team found could be used as a future biomarker that allows healthcare professionals to identify which course of chemotherapy is the most appropriate based on the cancer’s genetic makeup. This could prove particularly useful for children who develop these tumours around the current age cut-offs which determine the treatment they receive.
“We are excited to find genetic features that can be used to distinguish the tumours so clearly. Clinically, treating teenage and young adult patients can be challenging as they fall between paediatric and adult treatment protocols. It is important to treat them sufficiently but not excessively to avoid long-term side effects, so getting the intensity of the chemotherapy right is important. Our research suggests that the genetic makeup of the tumour might be used to help categorise such patients, which will hopefully result in children, and indeed all patients with germ cell tumours, getting the most appropriate therapy in the future.”
Dr Thomas Oliver, co-first author from the Wellcome Sanger Institute and Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
“Germ cell tumours can be made up of a variety of different tissues, including smooth muscle and skin, and previously very little was known about the factors behind their development, making them difficult to understand and treat. Our research has shown that these tumours can be traced back to the same genetic event, and the tissue types have developed from different branches of the same family tree, shedding more light on how these tumours are formed.”
Dr Raheleh Rahbari, co-senior author from the Wellcome Sanger Institute
“Germ cell tumours affect around 45 children in the UK every year. However, they can also develop at any age. Interestingly, our research found that early development signals, those which you see while a foetus is developing in the womb, can be found in these tumours. In the future, it may be possible to target these, as is done in some blood cancers, to give a new type of therapy for those with this type of cancer.”
Dr Sam Behjati, co-senior author from the Wellcome Sanger Institute and Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
Max Williamson, now 24, was diagnosed with testicular cancer at Bedford Hospital when he was 15 years old.
“I noticed a growing lump which was worrying, and when I went to my GP I was quickly referred to my local hospital which gave me my diagnosis. I had no history of cancer in my family. I was then referred to Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust for treatment. Whilst an operation removed the primary cancer, it rapidly spread to the lymph nodes in my abdomen and I had to undergo three courses of chemotherapy.”
“For me, an important part of experiencing cancer was trying to answer questions like ‘Why me?’ What happened to this part of my body to cause cancer? Nine years on, it’s so great to see the Cambridge team who looked after me (and many other researchers across the world) continuing to answer this question.”
Professor Matthew Murray, co-author on the paper and co-chair of the Biology Committee for the Malignant Germ Cell International Consortium, commented:
“Max had a malignant germ cell tumour, which is the leading adult cause for average years of life lost per person dying of cancer. When Max’s tumour changed from localised to metastatic – with the rapid spread to his lymph nodes – his treatment had to be urgently changed from follow-up surveillance to chemotherapy.”
“This study, which analysed both the DNA and RNA, found little relationship between the tissues the tumour made – what we can see down the microscope – and the changes found in the genetic code. Clearly, the tissue’s appearance doesn’t tell the whole story and underlines the needs for additional molecular tests that can accurately predict a tumour’s behaviour. The genetic patterns observed in this study are also a significant step forward in our understanding of these tumours, which, with more research, will aim to improve and personalise treatment of this type of cancer for patients like Max.”
This research took an in-depth look at the genetic differences in germ cell tumours and how they develop compared to other tissues. Currently, it is not known what causes the genetic events identified in this research, and these events are sporadic. They appear to happen by chance, and are not known to be caused by anything the mothers did or did not do during pregnancy.
- Types of Cancers That Develop in Young Adults. Available at: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-in-young-adults/cancers-in-young-adults.html [accessed May 2022]
- Germ Cell Tumours. Children with Cancer UK. Available at https://www.childrenwithcancer.org.uk/childhood-cancer-info/cancer-types/germ-cell-tumours/ [accessed April 2022]
- Germ Cell Tumours. NHS Inform. Available at: https://www.nhsinform.scot/illnesses-and-conditions/cancer/cancer-types-in-children/germ-cell-tumours [accessed April 2022]
T. Oliver, L. Chappell, R. Sanghvi, et al. (2022) Clonal diversification and histogenesis of malignant germ cell tumours. Nature Communications. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-022-31375-4
This research was part funded by Wellcome and Cancer Research UK. A full acknowledgement list can be found in the publication.
Related blog posts
13 May 2021
Maturation Block - Redefining Childhood Cancers
Using the latest genome sequencing techniques, Dr Sam Behjati is revealing the journey that cells take on their way to becoming ...
12 Jul 2022
Searching for the roots of childhood cancer
Meet Thomas Oliver, trainee pathologist and PhD student, working on the origins of childhood cancers.
2 Oct 2023
Contagious cancers in cockles sequenced, showing unexpected instability
The genomes of transmissible shellfish cancers have been sequenced for the first time, revealing levels of genomic instability not seen in ...
2 Oct 2023
Inigo Martincorenara receives Dr Josef Steiner Cancer Research Award 2023
Dr Inigo Martincorena has been awarded the Dr Josef Steiner Cancer Research Award 2023 for his research into the development of ...